A Symphony Of Diversity

How multifaceted voices amplify the literary world.

Mason Smith
An Injustice!
Published in
14 min readJan 7, 2024

--

Credit: We Need Diverse Books

Don’t forget to read to the end for your Think About It for the day, and if you’re interested in supporting me directly you can find all my links at www.linktr.ee/AsinTheJar. Without further ado, let’s get on with it!

The power move: Why diverse voices matter

Dismantling the idea that one culture speaks for all

Let’s cut the crap. Anyone who believes a single culture can represent the entirety of human experience is blissfully ignorant. Seriously, the audacity is staggering. Cultures are not interchangeable, and that’s not a bad thing. The more cultures we involve in the literary space, the richer the dialogue becomes. When diverse voices enter the conversation, we get to smash the toxic myth that one culture’s norms, traditions, and experiences are a blueprint for all of humanity. It’s like claiming one puzzle piece can complete the whole picture — absurd and insulting.

Gateways to unseen worlds: Exposing people to new stories

Imagine thinking you know the world but never stepping outside your front door. Yeah, no. Literature serves as a portal, inviting us into realms we otherwise wouldn’t access. But what’s the point if all the doors lead to the same room? Diverse voices aren’t just nice to have; they’re a necessity. They show us hidden realities, drag us into different dimensions of social issues, and sometimes — brace for it — even challenge our beliefs. It’s an emotional and intellectual road trip without the gas money, allowing us to ride shotgun through someone else’s life.

Evolving literary tropes: Shattering stereotypes

If I have to read one more story where the white saviour comes to rescue the ‘primitive’ locals, I might just hurl the book across the room — and I love books. Stereotypes in literature aren’t just dull; they’re damaging. They petrify outdated beliefs and legitimize prejudice. Enough is enough. When authors from varied backgrounds step up to the plate, they hit these tired tropes out of the park. Instead of clichés, we get nuance; instead of caricatures, we get fully fleshed-out characters. It’s an evolutionary leap in storytelling, and we’re here for it. No more cardboard cut-outs; give me a complex, multifaceted protagonist any day.

There you have it. Diverse voices aren’t just seasoning to the literary stew; they’re the essential ingredients that make the dish worth eating. From breaking the monolithic illusion to offering nuanced alternatives to tired tropes, these voices demand not just inclusion but center stage. And why? Because the real world isn’t homogenous. Our literature shouldn’t be either.

Can you hear me?: The silencing of minority voices

A brief history: Censorship and gatekeeping in the literary world

Hold the phone, because the narrative you’ve been spoon-fed? It’s been curated, sanitized, and bowdlerized by a centuries-old system of gatekeeping. For too long, a select group has played god, deciding whose stories are told and whose are shushed into oblivion. The reasons? Oh, the usual culprits: political power, societal norms, and a dash of outright discrimination. The grim result? A literary sphere that’s not just exclusive but blatantly exclusionary. And what gets axed? Works that challenge norms, question the status quo or simply come from authors whose identities don’t jive with mainstream tastes.

Colonial echo: How colonial powers imprinted their views on lit

Rolling in like a wrecking ball, colonial powers didn’t just snatch land and resources; they took over the narrative — literally. Books, scripts, and entire languages were subjugated, devalued, or erased. Ever heard of the British Empire labelling local cultures as “savage” while glorifying their colonial conquests in volumes of literature? Yeah, that wasn’t an isolated incident. This isn’t ancient history; the reverberations continue to infect our bookshelves and e-readers today. From erasing indigenous tales to lionizing colonial adventurers, the literary landscape is riddled with colonial fingerprints. It’s like seeing only one colour in a spectrum: limiting and utterly untrue.

“High culture” fallacy: How the canon skews white, and male

Get ready to gag: the so-called “high culture” in literature is essentially a VIP club with a discriminatory door policy. In this not-so-exclusive enclave, if you’re not a dead white European male, good luck getting in. Think Shakespeare, Hemingway, and Dickens have cornered the market on human insight? Guess again. This myopic focus disregards countless masterpieces from diverse cultures that delve into the human condition just as poignantly, if not more so. The literary canon, as it stands, isn’t just Eurocentric; it’s a distortion field, bending perception away from the multitude of stories that comprise the human experience.

Silencing marginalized voices in the literary world isn’t a bug; it’s a feature of a system constructed to maintain power dynamics. Whether it’s overt censorship, the colonial echo, or the snobbishness of “high culture,” the reality remains: many voices have been stifled. But acknowledging this isn’t about laying blame; it’s the first step to blasting the doors wide open for a more equitable, diverse literary sphere. So let’s get to it.

The rise of indie publishers and self-publishing

Creating space: Small publishers as the birthplace of diverse stories

Don’t wait for an invitation; build your own stage. That’s exactly what indie publishers are doing — laying down the bricks for authors who’ve been systematically sidelined. These aren’t just publishers; they’re revolutionaries in a paper and ink battleground. While big-name publishers often chase after the next blockbuster, these indie outfits are preoccupied with something far sexier: authentic, unheard narratives. They’re not just opening doors; they’re constructing entirely new buildings in the literary landscape. And guess what? It’s not a charity; it’s a thriving ecosystem where marginalized voices don’t just survive — they flourish.

DIY or die: Self-publishing as a tool for marginalized authors

Roll up those sleeves, because the future of diverse literature might just be a do-it-yourself affair. With platforms like Amazon Kindle, Smashwords, and Wattpad, who needs a publishing house? Self-publishing has democratized storytelling in a way that’s nothing short of radical. Marginalized authors are grabbing the mic for themselves, bypassing traditional gatekeepers who’ve historically dismissed them as too niche, too risky, or — let’s call a spade a spade — too threatening to the established order. But the numbers speak for themselves. Many self-published authors are racking up readers and, yes, making actual money. Time to put to bed the tired notion that self-publishing is just a vanity project.

The social media factor: Platforms that amplify lesser-heard voices

Ever shared a tweet that went viral? Then you know the power of social media to magnify voices that would otherwise fade into the background noise. For diverse authors, platforms like Twitter, Instagram, and TikTok serve as not just marketing tools, but as rallying cries for representation. Hashtags like #OwnVoices and #WeNeedDiverseBooks aren’t just trending topics; they’re social movements shaping the literary landscape in real time. No publisher? No problem. A strong social media presence can catapult an unknown author into a household name, or transform a marginalized narrative into a mainstream sensation.

We’re witnessing a seismic shift in the literary world. Indie publishers, self-publishing, and social media are the disruptive forces at the epicentre of this transformation. With these tools in hand, marginalized authors are not asking for space; they’re creating it, filling it, and inviting us all in for the experience of a lifetime.

The Money Talk: Profitability and Diverse Literature

Beating myths: Data shattering “diverse books don’t sell” argument

File this one under “Lies We’ve Been Told”: the myth that diverse books are a risky investment. Some execs in glass towers would have you believe there’s no market for diverse literature. Well, here’s a reality check for those naysayers — data shows that books featuring diverse characters and narratives often outsell their monochromatic counterparts. I’m talking real sales numbers, baby, not just wishful thinking. And it’s not just a feel-good movement; it’s a lucrative one. Take the “New York Times Best Sellers” list or the exponential growth in sales for books written by people of colour. The data doesn’t lie; diversity sells.

Book-to-film pipeline: Diverse books lead to successful adaptations

Forget unicorns; a genuinely diverse book-to-film adaptation is the real mythical creature we’ve all been searching for. But guess what? They exist, and they’re cash cows. Just look at hits like “Crazy Rich Asians,” “Black Panther,” or “The Hate U Give.” These aren’t just adaptations; they’re cultural phenomena that rake in the dough at the box office. The bonus? They often spark crucial social conversations, but let’s not forget their primary colour — green, as in the mountains of money they generate. Studios are catching on, realizing that if they adapt diverse literature, they’re not just expanding their audience; they’re lining their pockets.

Lit conferences: Economic benefits of spotlighting diversity

Do you think Lit Fests are just for beret-wearing, coffee-sipping intellectuals? Think again. These events are buzzing marketplaces, and the hot commodities are diverse authors. Featuring these voices isn’t just a noble endeavour; it’s a revenue booster. When Lit Fests give a platform to marginalized writers, attendance spikes, social media engagement soars, and — yes, you guessed it — books fly off the shelves. And what happens after the fest? Well, an engaged and enlarged readership often translates into sustained sales, not to mention the rippling economic benefits across the publishing ecosystem.

Time to kill the outdated notion that investing in diverse literature is some kind of charity work. It’s not; it’s smart business. From breaking sales records to turning heads in Hollywood, and elevating the economic vitality of literary events, diversity in literature isn’t just a societal demand — it’s a financial imperative.

Culture jamming: Intersecting identities in literature

Queer narratives: How LGBTQ+ perspectives enrich storylines

Scrap the cookie-cutter love stories and one-dimensional queer villains; it’s 2023, for crying out loud. LGBTQ+ perspectives in literature are adding more than just colour; they’re redefining what it means to live and love in all its nuanced splendour. Gay isn’t just a sidekick trope anymore; it’s a lens that can change the trajectory of a narrative, offering depth and angles hitherto unexplored. Novels that embed queer narratives don’t just contribute to diversity; they elevate the damn art form, forcing audiences to question not just the characters’ identities, but their preconceptions.

Cultural hybridity: Cultural intersections create complexity

Mash-ups aren’t just for DJs; they’re the heartbeat of stories that feature cultural hybridity. Imagine a story where Dia de los Muertos meets Lunar New Year. Sounds rad, right? Well, it is, and it’s also the future of literature. These are the spaces where assumptions meet their demise, and where single-story narratives go to die. The storylines emerging from such mash-ups aren’t just unique; they’re revolutionary, breaking the monotony of the cultural monoliths that have dominated the literary scene.

Intersectional feminism: Women of diverse backgrounds add layers

Forget the watered-down, all-lives-matter version of feminism that ignores the complex identities women carry. Intersectional feminism in literature addresses the big, gnarly knot of overlapping social categorizations like race, class, and gender. And let me tell you, it makes for some compelling storytelling. When you read about a Muslim lesbian navigating not just homophobia but also racism and religious intolerance, you’re not just reading a story; you’re participating in a discussion about multiple axes of identity. It’s not feminism lite; it’s feminism with full-bodied complexity.

Enough with the single-lane narratives and tunnel vision perspectives. Intersecting identities in literature aren’t just the toppings on the narrative pizza; they’re the very dough and sauce of storytelling today. And if literature aims to encapsulate the human experience, then it better start looking like the multifaceted, wonderfully complex species we are.

Critical lens: Analyzing how diversity shifts criticism

Shaking the tower: How diversity influences academic discourse

Throw out your pipe and elbow patches, academics; the ivory tower isn’t what it used to be, and thank goodness for that. Diversity in literature is doing more than just filling library shelves; it’s upending long-standing frameworks in academic discourse. Forget critiques confined to the hero’s journey or deconstructions of the male gaze. With more diverse literature comes a broader array of analytical lenses: post-colonial, queer theory, intersectional feminism — the list goes on. It’s not just diversity for the sake of diversity; it’s an intellectual shakeup that enriches our collective understanding of art and culture.

The growing role of critics from marginalized backgrounds

Move over, stale, pale, and male critics; there’s a new crew in town. Critics from marginalized backgrounds are finally getting the mic, and it’s not a minute too soon. These folks aren’t just reviewing books; they’re rewriting the rules of literary criticism. Suddenly, we see discussions of cultural appropriation, nuanced conversations about representation, and sharp analyses of systemic bias in storytelling. And they come with clout, influencing purchasing decisions and even shaping what kind of books get published in the first place. The critic’s chair isn’t a monolith anymore; it’s a vibrant tapestry of diverse perspectives.

Meta-narratives: The evolving themes and focus in literary criticism

If you thought literary criticism was all about dissecting symbolism in 19th-century novels, brace yourself for a shock. The entry of diverse voices into literature is creating new meta-narratives that critics can’t afford to ignore. We’re talking about the evolution of central themes that go beyond the old-school “man vs. society” or “woman as a symbol.” Now, we’re seeing the nuanced layering of critiques dealing with diaspora, identity fluidity, and systemic inequity. It’s not just new wine in old wineskins; it’s an entirely new kind of vintage that demands its own category of appreciation.

The kaleidoscope has been turned, and the patterns in literary criticism are far more intricate and colourful than before. This isn’t just a passing trend; it’s a fundamental shift in how we analyze and appreciate literature. So the next time you read a novel or critique, take a moment to notice the richness and depth added by diverse perspectives — it’s about time.

Actionable steps to amplify diversity in literature

Education: Incorporating diverse literature in school curriculums

Let’s get real. If To Kill a Mockingbird is the most diverse book a high-schooler reads, we’ve got work to do. Educational systems wield monumental power in shaping what gets read and, by extension, what gets valued. So, teachers and administrators, listen up: When you include books by diverse authors in the syllabus, you’re not just meeting a quota; you’re shaping a more equitable, empathetic future. This isn’t a token gesture; it’s a transformative one that imbues the next generation with a broader scope of human experience.

Book clubs and reading lists: Grassroots efforts making a difference

No more excuses, book clubbers. If your reading list is as white as the Chardonnay you’re sipping, it’s time for a refresh. Grassroots movements like book clubs can be game changers in amplifying diverse voices. Think about it: Every book you choose is a vote for the kind of world you want to see reflected in literature. Making room for diversity on your reading list isn’t just performative wokeness; it’s grassroots activism with a tangible impact. It’s a demand to publishers that says, “Hey, this is what we want to read, so get with the program.”

Inclusive awards: Rethinking criteria and juries for recognition

Ah, literary awards — the Oscars of the book world, often with just as much lack of diversity. Well, here’s a radical thought: Let’s reassess the criteria and juries that decide these awards. When juries are more diverse and when criteria expand to appreciate different kinds of storytelling, guess what happens? The spotlight swivels to works that might have otherwise languished in the shadows. And we’re not just doling out consolation prizes here; we’re acknowledging and elevating meritorious works that broaden the literary landscape.

Incorporating diversity into literature isn’t just an aesthetic choice; it’s a moral and societal imperative. From what gets taught in schools to what gets debated in book clubs, and even what gets celebrated in award shows, every choice counts. So go ahead, take these actionable steps and be part of the change — you’ll be in good company.

Echo chamber: Projections for diversity in literature

Tech innovations: How AI and platforms may democratize writing

Imagine you’re wearing VR goggles, navigating a digital realm written by a queer Indigenous author from Australia. Mind-blowing, right? Tech isn’t just about bells and whistles; it’s a seismic force that’s primed to democratize storytelling. AI-generated plots and VR-enriched narratives aren’t just the stuff of sci-fi; they’re near-future realities that could let underrepresented authors break new ground. No, this isn’t tech gimmickry; this is a revolution in accessibility that obliterates the barriers between storytellers and audiences.

Global village: Impact of translated works and international authors

Ever read a book and felt like you’d taken a whirlwind trip around the world? Translated works and international authors are here to whisk you away to uncharted landscapes, culturally and literally. Globalization is shrinking our world, and that’s great news for diverse literature. The influx of translated works is more than a spice added to a bland dish; it’s a full-course meal that satisfies a range of palates. It’s time to recognize that the literary universe isn’t confined to English-speaking corners; it’s a bustling global village with a cacophony of voices waiting to be heard.

Farewell to gatekeepers: The erosion of traditional barriers to entry

Remember when getting published was as complex as cracking a safe? Those days are fading, and we’re not shedding any tears. The erosion of traditional barriers — think publishing houses with more gatekeepers than a medieval fortress — isn’t a threat to literature; it’s a rebirth. As indie publishers rise and self-publishing becomes less stigmatized, the power dynamics are shifting. This isn’t a compromise in quality; it’s an opening of floodgates for talent that has been kept at bay for far too long.

So, what’s the future of diverse voices in literature? It’s as expansive and limitless as the imagination of the countless authors waiting to be read. And if you’re not excited by that, you might be reading the wrong books.

Final Beats: Why This Isn’t Just a Trend

Beyond tokenism: The lasting impact of diversity in literature

You’ve seen the “hot new trend” articles — the ones that make diversity in literature sound like the literary version of a fidget spinner. We need to jettison this narrative right out the window. Diversity is not a fad, it’s the overdue normalization of voices that reflect our world’s complexity. When literature embraces this ethos, it doesn’t just “add colour” to the narrative; it redefines the very notion of what a narrative can be. So, forget the trend pieces; what we’re witnessing is a foundational shift that’s altering the DNA of storytelling.

Stories as resistance: How literature acts as both mirror and window

Do stories create the world or merely reflect it? Trick question — they do both. Literature as resistance isn’t just a tagline; it’s a call to arms. When marginalized communities craft their narratives, they’re not just scratching words on a page; they’re forging weapons of empathy and insight. These stories serve as mirrors that let us see ourselves in new ways and windows that offer vistas into lives we might not otherwise encounter. This isn’t sentimental fluff; it’s hardcore, radical activism through storytelling.

Legacy: What we can gain from diverse literature

Forget the Pulitzer or the Nobel; the real prize is the legacy we leave behind for future generations. This isn’t about book sales or bestseller lists; it’s about the kind of world we’re mapping out for those who come after us. A diverse literary landscape isn’t just a gift to our future selves; it’s an inheritance for the youngsters who will one day discover themselves in the pages they turn. And let’s be clear: We’re not just passing the torch; we’re igniting a bonfire that will illuminate the world long after we’re gone.

In a nutshell, diversity in literature is not an expendable luxury — it’s a necessity. It’s the vital heartbeat of a culture that refuses to flatline. So, let’s keep the rhythm going. Because this is far from a trend; it’s the soundtrack to our evolving world.

Thanks for reading! Clapping, sharing, highlighting, commenting, and adding to a reading list are all great things you can do to help me grow!

As always, bigotry or any defence of bigotry in my comments will not be tolerated. That goes for devil advocates, too. Be kind, equitable, and inclusive.

Do you have any book, comic book, graphic novel, or TV recommendations authored by diverse people? Feel free to let me know in the comments and please tag me and link to my article if you want to respond in your own article!

Sign up to discover human stories that deepen your understanding of the world.

Free

Distraction-free reading. No ads.

Organize your knowledge with lists and highlights.

Tell your story. Find your audience.

Membership

Read member-only stories

Support writers you read most

Earn money for your writing

Listen to audio narrations

Read offline with the Medium app

--

--

Published in An Injustice!

A new intersectional publication, geared towards voices, values, and identities!

Written by Mason Smith

I'm Mason, as in the jar. I'm a DEI communicator. Patreon: patreon.com/AsInTheJar. Linktree: linktr.ee/AsInTheJar

Responses (2)

What are your thoughts?